• Home
  • Pay Calculator
  • Pay Matrix
  • DA Table
  • NPS to OPS
  • OROP

CENTRAL GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES NEWS

7th PAY COMMISSION, 7th CPC NEWS, 7th CENTRAL PAY COMMISSION, 7th PAY SCALE, 7th PROJECTED PAY SCALE, 7th EXPECTED PAY SCALE, EXPECTED DA, DOPT ORDERS

  • Pay Tools
    • 7th CPC Pay & Allowances Calculator July 2017
    • 7th CPC Defence Pay Arrears Calculator
    • 6th to 7th CPC Pay Conversion Tool
    • 6th to 7th CPC Pay & Arrears Calculator
    • 7th CPC Pay & Allowances Calculator in Hindi
    • First Month Pay Calculator for CG Employees
    • 7th CPC Pay Calculator for Scientists of ICAR
    • Defence PBOR Pay Calculator
    • GDS Pay and Arrears Calculator 2018
    • Expected 7th CPC Calculator 2015
  • Pension Tools
    • 6th CPC Pension Calculator
    • DL-33 Arrears Calculator
    • 5th CPC Pension Calculator
    • Commutation of Pension Calculator
    • 7th CPC Defence Pension Calculator 2016
    • Pre-2006 Pension Calculator(With or Without DP)
    • 7th CPC Family Pension Arrears Calculator
  • Fixation Tools
    • 7th CPC Pay Fixation on Promotion & MACP Calculator
    • 7th CPC Pay Matrix : Increment Anomaly Indicator
    • 7th CPC Pay Fixation Calculator
    • 7th CPC Expected HRA Calculator 2016 – Updated
    • 7th CPC HRA Calculator as per Cabinet Decision
    • HRA Income Tax Exemption Calculator for Govt Employees
    • Income Tax Calculator – Pre & Post Budget 2017
    • INCOME TAX FORM 16 CALCULATOR
    • 7th CPC Allowances Search Box With Report Page
    • Expected Bank DA Calculator from Nov 2018
    • DA Calculator for CPSE Employees
    • Expected DA Jan 2019 Calculation Tool
  • Dopt Orders
    • All Dopt Orders 2018
    • 7th CPC Dopt Orders
    • Dopt Orders 2019
    • Dopt Orders 2018
    • Dopt Orders 2017
    • Dopt Orders 2016
    • dopt Orders 2015
    • Dopt Orders 2014
  • VII CPC NEWS
    • 7th CPC Allowances
    • 7th CPC TA
    • 7th CPC Pay Fixation
    • 7th CPC CEA
    • 7th CPC MACP
    • 7th CPC LTC
    • 7th CPC Holidays
    • 7th CPC HRA
You are here: Home / Departmental Promotion Committee / Guidelines on treatment of effect of penalties on promotion — role of Departmental Promotion Committee

7th CPC Pay Matrix Table for Defence Force Personnel
NPS To OPS: Cabinet Approved Contribution 10% to 14%
7th CPC Post-2006 Pension Calculator
CSD Car Prices March 2018 – Delhi Depot
Read All Recent Comments and Reply
Trending Calculators Popular Topics
Commutation Value of Pension Calculator Pay Matrix Chart (Level 1 to 5)
Pay Fixation on Promotion & MACP Calculator Pay Matrix Chart (Level 6 to 9)
Check Your Increment Eqaul to 3%? Pay Matrix Chart (Level 10 to 12)
Expected DA & DR Calculator (Updated) Pay Matrix Chart Level (13 to 14)
Latest 7th Pay Commission News Current DoPT Orders
Latest News on Retirement Age 62 Latest Posts (First 50 Updates)

Guidelines on treatment of effect of penalties on promotion — role of Departmental Promotion Committee

April 28, 2014 Leave a Comment

Click For Latest Posts(Recent Entries)

Guidelines on treatment of effect of penalties on promotion — role of Departmental Promotion Committee

No. 22011/4/2007-Estt. (D)
Government of India
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pension
Department of Personnel & Training

North Block, New Delhi,
Dated the 28th April, 2014

OFFICE MEMORANDUM

Subject: Guidelines on treatment of effect of penalties on promotion — role of Departmental Promotion Committee

The Department of Personnel & Training had in its O.M. No.22011/5/86-Estt (D) dated 10.04.1989 issued consolidated instructions on Departmental Promotion Committee and matters related thereto. Para 6.2.3 of said O.M. provides that “before making the overall grading after considering the CRs for the relevant years, the DPC should take into account whether the officer has been awarded any major or minor penalty or whether any displeasure of any superior officer or authority has been conveyed to him as reflected in the ACRs.” These guidelines further provide that “the DPC should not be guided merely by the overall grading, if any, that may be recorded in the ACRs (now APARs) but should also make its own assessment on the basis of entries in the CRs (now APARs) because it has been noticed that sometimes the overall grading in a ACR (now APAR) may be inconsistent with the grades under various parameters or attributes”

2. It further provides that an officer whose increments have been withheld or who has been reduced to a lower stage in the time scale, cannot be considered on that account to be ineligible for promotion to the higher grade as the specific penalty of withholding promotion has not been imposed on him/her. The suitability of the officer for promotion should be assessed by the DPC as and when occasions arise for such assessment. In assessing the suitability, the DPC will take into account the circumstances leading to the imposition of the penalty and decide whether in the light of the general service record of the officer and the fact of the imposition of the penalty he should be considered suitable for promotion. However, even where the DPC considers that despite the penalty, the officer is suitable for promotion, the officer should not be actually promoted during the currency of the penalt

3. Further this Department’s O.M. No. No.22034/5/2004-Estt (D) dated 15.12.2004 provides that a Government servant, on whom a minor penalty of withholding of increment etc. has been imposed, should be considered for promotion by the Departmental Promotion Committee which meets after the imposition of the said penalty and after due consideration of full facts leading to imposition of the penalty, if he is still considered fit for promotion, the promotion may be given effect after the expiry of the currency of the penalt

4. The procedure and guidelines to be followed for promotion of Government servants against whom disciplinary/court proceedings are pending or whose conduct is under investigation has been laid down in this Department’s O.M. No.22011/4/91-Estt(A) dated 14.9.92 and O.M. No.22034/4/2012-Estt (D) dated 02.11.2012 and 23.1.2014

5. The role of Departmental Promotion Committee(DPC) in assessment of the officers being considered for promotion, including the officer(s) against whom a chargesheet has been issued or on whom a penalty has been imposed, has been examined by the Supreme Court in several judgments. The observations of Supreme Court in some of the important cases are summarized as under:

(a) In A.K. Narula case (AIR 2007 SC 2296), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed:
“the guidelines give a certain amount of play in the joints to the DPC by providing that it need not be guided by the overall grading recorded in the CRs, but may make its own assessment on the basis of the entries in the CRs. The DPC is required to make an overall assessment of the performance of each candidate separately, but by adopting the same standards, yardsticks and norms. It is only when the process of assessment is vitiated either on the ground of bias, malafide or arbitrariness, the selection calls for interference. Where the DPC has proceeded in a fair, impartial and reasonable manner, by applying the same yardstick and norms to all candidates and there is no arbitrariness in the process of assessment by the DPC, the court will not interfere”.

(b) In Union of India vs. K.V. Jankiraman case(AIR 1991 SC 2010), the Supreme Court has taken cognizance of role of DPC the case of an officer on whom a penalty has been imposed and has held that:

“An employee has no right to promotion. He has only right to be considered for promotion. The promotion to a post and more so, to a selection post, depends upon several circumstances. To qualify for promotion, the least that is expected of an employee is to have an unblemished record. That is the minimum expected to ensure a clean and efficient administration and to protect the public interest. An employee found guilty of misconduct cannot be placed on par with the other employees, and his case has to be treated differently……. In fact, while considering an employee for promotion his whole record has to be taken into consideration and if a promotion committee takes the penalties imposed upon the employee into consideration and denies him the promotion, such denial is not illegal and unjustified.”

(c) In UOI & Anr. Vs. S.K. Goel & Ors. (Appeal (Civil) 689/2007 -SLP(C)-2410/2007), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that:

“DPC enjoyed full discretion to devise its method and procedure for objective assessment of suitability and merit of the candidate being considered by it. Hence interference by High Court is not called for. ”

While delivering the above judgement, the Division Bench has observed that:
“…it is now more or less well settled that the evaluation made by an Expert Committee should not be easily interfered with by the Court which do not have the necessary expertise to undertake the exercise that is necessary for such purpose.”

6. It has been brought to the notice of this Department that DPCs have been adopting varying criteria in assessment of officials undergoing penalty that are not consistent with the extant instructions of the DOPT for e.g., downgradation of grading in ACR/APAR, denying promotion for specified number of years, etc.

7. The matter has been examined in consultation with the Department of Legal Affairs. It is a settled position that the DPC, within its power to make its own assessment, has to assess every proposal for promotion, on case to case basis. In assessing the suitability, the DPC is to take into account the circumstances leading to the imposition of the penalty and decide, whether in the light of general service record of the officer and the effect of imposition of penalty, he/she should be considered suitable for promotion and therefore, downgradation of APARs by one level in all such cases may not be legally sustainable. Following broad guidelines are laid down in respect of DPC:

a) DPCs enjoy full discretion to devise their own methods and procedures for objective assessment of the suitability of candidates who are to be considered by them, including those officers on whom penalty has been imposed as provided in DoPT O.M. dated 10.4.89 and O.M. dated 15.12.2004.

b) The DPC should not be guided merely by the overall grading, if any, that may be recorded in the ACRs/APARs but should make its own assessment on the basis of the entries in the ACRs/APARs as it has been noticed that sometimes the overall grading in a ACR/APAR may be inconsistent with the grading under various parameters or attributes. Before making the overall recommendation after considering the APARs (earlier ACRs) for the relevant years, the DPC should take into account whether the officer has been awarded any major or minor penalty.(Refer para 6.2.1(e) and para 6.2.3 of DoPT OM dated 10.04.89)

c) In case, the disciplinary/criminal prosecution is in the preliminary stage and the officer is not yet covered under any of the three conditions mentioned in para 2 of DoPT O.M. dated 14.09.1992, the DPC will assess the suitability of the officer and if found fit, the officer will be promoted along with other officers. As provided in this Department’s O.M. dated 02.11.2012, the onus to ensure that only person with unblemished records are considered for promotion and disciplinary proceedings, if any, against any person coming in the zone of consideration are expedited, is that of the administrative Ministry/Department.

d) If the official under consideration is covered under any of the three condition mentioned in para 2 of O.M. dated 14.09.1992, the DPC will assess the suitability of Government servant along with other eligible candidates without taking into consideration the disciplinary case/criminal prosecution pending. The assessment of the DPC including ‘unfit for promotion’ and the grading awarded are kept in a sealed cover. (Para 2.1 of DoPT OM dated 14.9.92).

e) Para 7 of DoPT OM dated 14.09.92 provides that a Government servant, who is recommended for promotion by the DPC, but in whose case, any of the three circumstances on denial of vigilance clearance mentioned in para 2 of ibid O.M. arises after the recommendations of the DPC are received but before he/she is actually promoted, will be considered as if his/her case had been placed in a sealed cover by the DPC. He/she shall not be promoted until he/she is completely exonerated of the charges against him/her.

f) If any penalty is imposed on the Government servant as a result of the disciplinary proceedings or if he/she is found guilty in the criminal prosecution against him/her, the findings of the sealed cover/covers shall not be acted upon. His/her case for promotion may be considered by the next DPC in the normal course and having regard to the penalty imposed on him/her (para 3.1 of DoPT OM dated 14.9.92).

g) In assessing the suitability of the officer on whom a penalty has been imposed, the DPC will take into account the circumstances leading to the imposition of the penalty and decide whether in the light of general service record of the officer and the fact of imposition of penalty, the officer should be considered for promotion. The DPC, after due consideration, has authority to assess the officer as ‘unfit’ for promotion. However, where the DPC considers that despite the penalty the officer is suitable for promotion, the officer will be actually promoted only after the currency of the penalty is over (para 13 of DoPT OM dated 10.4.89).

h) Any proposal for promotion has to be assessed by the DPC, on case to case basis, and the practice of downgradation of APARs (earlier ACRs) by one level in all cases for one time, where a penalty has been imposed in a year included in the assessment matrix or till the date of DPC should be discontinued immediately, being legally non-sustainable.

i) While there is no illegality in denying promotion during the currency of the penalty, denying promotion in such cases after the period of penalty is over would be in violation of the provisions of Article 20 of the Constitution

j) The appointing authorities concerned should review comprehensively the cases of Government servants, whose suitability for promotion to a higher grade has been kept in a sealed cover on the expiry of 6 months from the date of convening the first Departmental Promotion Committee which had adjudged his suitability and kept its findings in the sealed cover. Such a review should be done subsequently also every six months. The review should, inter alia, cover the progress made in the disciplinary proceedings/criminal prosecution and the further measures to be taken to expedite the completion. (Para 4 of O.M. dated 14.09.1992)

k) In cases where the disciplinary case/criminal prosecution against the Government servant is not concluded even after the expiry of two years from the date of the meeting of the first DPC which kept its findings in respect of the Government servant in a sealed cover then subject to condition mentioned in Para 5 of this Department’s O.M. dated 14.09.1992, the appointing authority may consider desirability of giving him ad-hoc promotion (Para 5 of this Department’s O.M. dated 14.09.1992).

8. All the administrative authorities in the Ministries/Department are advised to place relevant records, including chargesheet, if any, issued to the officer concerned, penalty imposed, etc., before the DPC/ACC who will decide the suitability of officer for promotion keeping in view the general service records of the officer including the circumstances leading to the imposition of the chargesheet or penalty imposed. If such an officer is found suitable, promotion will be given effect after the currency of the penalty is over.
9. All Ministries/Departments are, therefore, requested to keep in view the above guidelines while convening DPC for promotion of the Government servants on whom either penalty has been imposed or where there are adverse remarks in the reckonable ACRs/APARs.

sd/-
(Mukta Goel)
Director

Source: www.persmin.nic.in
[http://ccis.nic.in/WriteReadData/CircularPortal/D2/D02est/22011_4_2007-Estt.D-28042014.pdf]

Latest Comments on 7th Pay Commission News

Related to Your Search
    Model Calendar for the Departmental Promotion Committees – Dopt Orders
    Procedure for conduct of supplementary DPC – Dopt issued orders with illustration
    Inclusion of eligible officers who are due to retire before the likely date of vacancies, in the panel for promotion
    Eligibility of officers to be considered for promotion by DPC- Fixing of Crucial Date–Dopt Orders
    Fixation of pay of State Government Employees on their appointment in Central Government, subsequent to implementation of CCS (RP) Rules, 2008
    Clarification regarding Pay fixation on grant of Non-Functional Upgradation
    Timely and advance action in convening of Departmental Promotion Committee meeting in terms of Model Calendar – Dopt Instructions
    Promotion for IAS Officers – Promotion Guidelines reviewed by Dopt
    DoPT is Trying its Best to Clear the Backlog of Promotions

Filed Under: Departmental Promotion Committee, DOPT, Dopt Orders, Dopt Orders on Promotion Tagged With: Departmental Promotion Committee, Dopt, Dopt orders, DPC

Civilian Pay Matrix Chart

7th CPC Pay Matrix Level-1 to 5

Civilian Pay Matrix Chart

7th CPC Pay Matrix Level-6 to 9

Civilian Pay Matrix Chart

7th CPC Pay Matrix Level-10 to 12

Civilian Pay Matrix Chart

7th CPC Pay Matrix Level-13 to 14

Civilian Pay Matrix Chart

7th CPC Pay Matrix Level-15 to 18

Share & Like Our Posts in Facebook
Ever Green Topics
VII CPC PAY FIXATION
VII CPC MACP SCHEME
VII CPC HOLIDAYS
VII CPC TRANSPORT ALLOWANCE
VII CPC HOUSE RENT ALLOWANCE (197)
VII CPC TRAVELLING ALLOWANCE
VII CPC LEAVE TRAVEL CONCESSION
VII CPC CHILDREN EDUCATION ALLOWANCE
VII CPC INCREMENT(ANOMALY)
VII CPC FITMENT FACTOR(2.57)
VII CPC ALLOWANCES
VII CPC HBA
VII CPC CHILD CARE LEAVE
VII CPC CLASSIFICATINO OF POSTS
VII CPC ADVANCES
VII CPC HARDSHIP MATRIX ALLOWANCES
Imporant Tables
DA TABLE FOR V, VI AND VIICPC
OROP TABLES FROM 1 to 101 FOR EX-SERVICEMEN
PENSION READY RECKONER CONCORDANCE TABLES 1 TO 58
7th CPC CONCORDANCE TABLES FOR CG PENSIONERS
OROP TABLE NO.7 FOR JCOs/ORs
5TH CPC, 6TH CPC AND 7th CPC DA TABLE
HOLIDAY HOMES ADDRESS AND CONTACT DETAILS
197 ALLOWANCES AS PER 7TH CPC
7th CPC DEFENCE NATIONAL PAY CONCORDANCE TABLES
DA CALCULATION TABLES
Most Visited & Commented Posts
7th Pay Commission Pay Scale Calculator
[Published on:21.11.2015, Comments:718, Shares:5.0k]
Projected OROP Table PBOR and Officers
[Published on:05.02.2015, Comments:692, Shares:1.1k]
Projected OROP Table PBOR
[Published on:20.12.2014, Comments:989, Shares:600]
Pay Scales for PBORs of Armed Forces
[Published on:04.03.2014, Comments:594, Shares:457]
7th CPC Pension Calculation
[Published on:08.10.2013, Comments:579, Shares:294]
7th CPC Pension Calculator for Pre-2016 CG Pensioners
[Published on:24.11.2015, Comments:528, Shares:1.1.k]
Expected Pay Calculator as per 7th Pay Commission
[Published on:10.03.2015, Comments:518, Shares:3.4k]
7th CPC Voluntary Retirement Scheme
[Published on:08.10.2013, Comments:293, Shares:39]
7th CPC Projected Pay Scale
[Published on:08.10.2013, Comments:248, Shares:119]
7th CPC Pension Fixation for Pre-2016 Pensioners
[Published on:22.11.2015, Comments:248, Shares:362]
7th CPC minimum Pension for JCOs/ ORs
[Published on:24.11.2015, Comments:225, Shares:212]
OROP Table No.7 – JCOs/ORs Including Honorary Commissioned Officers
[Published on:04.02.2016, Comments:240, Shares:255]

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Recent Comments

  • M.K.Kumar on 7th CPC Voluntary Retirement Scheme
  • Ajay vg on Latest News on Retirement Age 62
  • Naveen on 7th CPC Voluntary Retirement Scheme
  • M.K.KUMAR on 7th CPC Increment
  • Shabana parveen on 7th CPC Increment
  • M.K.KUMAR on 7th CPC Projected Pay Scale
  • Mysore Maharaj on 7th CPC Voluntary Retirement Scheme
  • M.K.KUMAR on 7th CPC Pay Fixation on Promotion & MACP Calculator
  • M.K.KUMAR on 7th CPC Pay Fixation on Promotion & MACP Calculator
  • archna on 7th CPC Voluntary Retirement Scheme

Click to View All Comments in a Single Page

Updated Topics

7th CPC Orders for CG Employees, Defence Personnel & Pensioners (7 वीं वेतन आयोग ताजा खबर)
Current DoPT Orders - नवीनतम डीओपीटी ऑर्डर
New Pension System To Old Pension Scheme (पुरानी पेंशन योजना को किया जाए बहाल)
Latest News on Retirement Age of CG Employees - सीजी कर्मचारियों की सेवानिवृत्ति आयु
Civil and Defence Pensioners Issues – पेंशन शिकायत प्रकोष्ठ
One Rank One Pension Orders & Tables (एक रैंक एक पेंशन - एमओडी आदेश)
Children Education Allowance and Hostel Subsidy (बच्चों के शिक्षा भत्ता)
Holidays for CG Employees and Offices (केंद्र सरकार के कर्मचारियों के लिए छुट्टियां)
CSD Car, Bike & Scooter Prices (CSD कार, बाइक और स्कूटर की कीमत)
GDS Latest News (ग्रामीण डाक सेवक ताज़ा खबर)
CGHS Hospitals for All Cities (सभी शहरों के लिए सीजीएचएस अस्पताल)
KV School Admission 2019-20 (केवी स्कूल एडमिशन)
NC JCM Meeting Discussions & Decisions (NC JCM बैठक निर्णय)
7th CPC MACP Scheme (7 वीं सीपीसी MACP योजना)
11th Bipartite Settlements (11 वीं द्विपक्षीय बस्तियों)
Finance Ministry Orders (वित्त मंत्रालय आदेश)
National Pension System (नेशनल पेंशन सिस्टम)
Leave Travel Concession (छुट्टी यात्रा रियायत)

Pay Matrix Tables

CIVILIAN PAY MATRIX
LEVEL 1 to 5
LEVEL 6 to 9
LEVEL 10 to 12
LEVEL 13 to 14
LEVEL 15 to 18
DEFENCE PAY MATRIX
LEVEL 3 to 5
LEVEL 5a to 9
LEVEL 10 to 11
LEVEL 12 to 14

VII CPC TOPICS

7th Pay Commission News
7th CPC Fitment Factor
7th CPC Pay Matrix Tables
7th CPC Pay Fixation
7th CPC Allowances
7th CPC CCL
7th CPC Transport Allowance
7th CPC Travelling Allowance
7th CPC Advances
7th CPC AICPIN
7th CPC HRA
7th CPC CEA
7th CPC Post Classification
7th CPC DA Calculation
7th CPC HRA
7th CPC HBA
7th CPC LTC
7th CPC Leave
7th CPC Increment
7th CPC MACP
7th CPC NPS
7th CPC Pension
7th CPC Pension Calculation
7th CPC Pension Tables

Category Headlines

7th Pay Commission News | 972 Posts
Dopt Orders | 341 Posts
Expected DA | 127 Posts
OROP Tables | 255
Pensioners Issue | 210 Posts
CGHS | 184 Posts
Uncategorized | 145 Posts
Dopt Orders 2015 | 126 Posts
Concordance Tables | 113 Posts
Confederation News | 123 Posts
Bank Employees News | 122 Posts
Income Tax | 107 Posts
Defence Pensioners | 104 Posts
NC JCM Staff Side | 103 Posts
Finmin Orders | 99 Posts
Dopt Orders | 98 Posts
Bonus | 87 Posts
LTC Rules | 87 Posts
NPS | 87 Posts
Employment News | 84 Posts
MACP | 84 Posts
CSD Price List | 79 Posts
Dopt Orders on CCS Rules | 76 Posts
Holidays | 71 Posts
DA Orders | 70 Posts
Retirement Age | 66 Posts
KV School Admission | 53 Posts
HRA | 48 Posts
Children Education Allowance | 48 Posts
7th CPC Dopt Orders | 45 Posts
FREE EMAIL SUBSCRIPTION

Enter your email address:

We will send activation email immediately to you. Don't forget to click the activation link.

Copyright © 2019 - Central Government Employees News - 7th Pay Commission News